"It was Twenty Years ago today!"
article published 23rd August, 2017, but first written in 1997 by the late Brian Judson (with additional comments by the webmaster)
This report was provided by Brian Judson. It is followed by my
ecstatic observations about the debut of Jose Dominguez. Note
that at the time, I had some misguided misgivings about the one
and only David Ginola!
Saturday, August 23rd, 1997
FA Carling Premiership
TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR (1) 1, DERBY COUNTY (0) 0.
Tottenham Hotspur : Walker; Carr, Scales, Calderwood,
Edinburgh; Howells, Sinton (sub Neilsen, 76), Ginola (sub
Dominguez, 34), Clemence; Ferdinand, Iversen.
Substitutes *NOT* used : Baardsen, Mabbutt, Fox.
Booked : Edinburgh, Nielsen.
Goalscorer : Calderwood, 45
Derby County : Poom; C Powell, Stimac, Lausen, Eranio; Dailly,
Hunt (sub Solis, 72), Van den Laan (sub D Powell, 72), Carsley;
Ward, Burton (sub Sturridge, 60).
Substitutes *NOT* used : Hoult, Rowett.
Booked : Eranio, Laursen, Carsley, Stimac.
Referee : M J Bodenham (East Looe).
Attendance : 25,886.
Tottenham won this match, which is something most Spurs fans
were grateful for as they left White Hart Lane. However, much of
the football on view from both sides was fumbling with far too
many players over-kicking the ball, thus losing possession to the
opposition. Spurs players seemed to feel as though they were
strangers to each other, making repeated mistakes and being
caught in possession of the ball frequently. It was a messy,
unsightly game and one that few will want to recall in years to
Following an annoying 10 day break for World Cup matches that
England were not involved in, Tottenham returned to White Hart
Lane for a home game with Derby County. Having lost their first
two matches, it was vital Tottenham extracted something from this
match if they were not to be dogged by a season's struggle
against relegation, particularly in view of the bright start
Arsenal have made to their season. The usual long litany of
injuries were included in the pre-match reports and included the
colossus that Sol Campbell has become in the Tottenham defence.
Despite treatment, his knee injury had not responded and he was
forced to miss the match. Surprisingly, Calderwood was preferred
to Mabbutt but, perhaps in the light of events, it was probably
just as well that he played.
Derby had comfortably survived their first season in the
Premiership, finishing 12th. They had been regarded as one of the
favourites for relegation but had seldom been in trouble. Jim
Smith had strengthened his squad during the summer months but
surprisingly, in view of the problems given to the Tottenham
defence in the corresponding match last August, (Dean) Sturridge was
initially confined to the bench.
The opening half hour was so awful that I am sure most of the
spectators must have wished they had stayed at home to enjoy the
sunshine. Certainly I have rarely viewed so many players
demonstrating perfectly how *NOT* to play football. Their first
touch was awful. Too many laid the ball off too early or too late
or were caught in possession. Walker's upfield kicking towards
the Edmonton end was atrociously poor, quite often leaving
Ferdinand and Iversen stranded in no man's land.
But it does have to be said of Derby that their tackling was
very crude. It was obvious their intention was to preserve their
goal and snatch a point. I felt that Mr Bodenham should have
stamped on some of the crude tackling at a much earlier stage
than he did. Certainly, Stimac clattered into Ginola at every
opportunity without even receiving a finger waving from an
official who seemed to be semi-detached from the mayhem
The spectators were becoming visibly restless when Stimac
clattered Ginola yet again. Ginola needed lengthy treatment and
jogged around clutching his shoulder for some minutes afterwards.
He showed no enthusiasm for playing after that and was seen
pleading to be substituted. In the end, Ginola was called off in
the 34th minute and Jose Dominguez appeared on the touchline.
Once Dominguez came on, he soon had the fans roaring approval
as he buzzed around like an angry wasp, running rings around the
Derby defenders. Derby quickly put three defenders around him as
soon as he received the ball but he was too quick for them,
spinning round and round until the Derby defenders banged into
each other, leaving the way to goal open like the parting of the
Red Sea in times past.
As the referee looked at his watch, Dominguez won a free kick.
Sinton took the free kick and a blur of white bulleted into a
packed penalty area to head the ball home. When the
congratulations had faded, we found Calderwood grinning broadly
at the bottom of the pack. There was scarcely time to restart the
match before the halftime whistle echoed.
The second half was a huge improvement on the first half but
still too much football reminded one of the pinball wizard rather
than push and run. But the goal had worked wonders for
Tottenham's confidence and had gnawed at Derby's during the
Tottenham, with Clemence, Sinton and Dominguez as chief
tormentors, started to put passes together that suggests that
Dominguez may well be the player we have been looking for for a
very long time. He seemed to bring out the best in those around
him, particularly in the very young Clemence, who seems already
to be a fixture in the Tottenham team. It is hard to realise that
Clemence has only broken into the first team this season as his
play and approach is so mature.
Derby tried to change their approach by sending on three
substitutes including Sturridge, with half an hour to go. But
Tottenham's tails were up and the crowd roared every time
Dominguez received the ball. It has been a very long time since I
have felt a roar of anticipation generated by the presence of one
player. Probably the last player to evoke a response like that
was Gazza in 1990-91 .......
Right at the end, Spurs could and should have increased their
lead. Injury time seemed to go on for ever. Something like five
or six minutes must have been added by the referee to the game.
And then Dominguez was sent flying in the penalty area. Howells
stepped forward to take the kick and ballooned the ball over the
So, not a game to remember, apart from Dominguez's debut. The
smallest player to represent Tottenham since Phil Holder in the
1980s, he may well be the smallest player ever. Yet he has a
heart that is as strong as Dave Mackay's or Alan Mullery's,
charging everywhere, trying to lift those around him.
On Wednesday evening we entertain Aston Villa, who are rock
bottom of the League. Hopefully, Dominguez will start the game
and help us to beat a team that seems to have had the indian sign
on us for far too long.
Editor's comments, also written in 1997
At last - mine eyes have seen some glory! It was in the
diminutive shape of Jose DOMINGUEZ. Bruce ( a reference to friend and former fellow webmaster Bruce Lewis)- you must have been
privileged to have seen his performance against Southend
reserves. I only wish I had been there with you. I don't remember
reading anything on the list about his performance at Swindon,
where he played the other night. The point I am making is that I
would pay money, and travel almost anywhere to watch this little
dynamo. HE IS THE MOST EXCITING FOOTBALLER I'VE SEEN AT THE LANE
SINCE JK. He is fast, he beats players; he has brilliant powers
of recovery, retaining the ball a couple of times even after
falling over; he seems to have all the tricks in the book,
including the Ryan GIGGS trailing leg trick. I kid you not when I
say that every time he had the ball, he set the crowd alight, and
had the Derby players totally flummoxed.
The papers today will probably say "OLES RING OUT FOR
JOSE", and that's how it was. It was the best home
atmosphere for ages ( I missed the ManU game ). Even on this
first appearance, there can be no doubt that DOMINGUEZ is real
class, with electric pace, and that he is without doubt the best
signing Gerry has made. The great thing is that the little man
was interviewed ater the game, and he says he still isn't fully
fit! So, there's more to come! I can't wait to see him on
Wednesday. He must be the first on the team sheet. He reminded a
lot of people around me of Ossie, but he is a lot faster.
DOMINGUEZ is the player that GINOLA should have been for us,
but isn't. (Little did I know!)It appears that GINOLA went off after 33 minutes with
a shoulder injury, but he was making no impression, and made one
or two elementary mistakes. There ain't going to be room for both
of them in the side, and in my view there is no question of who
should be first choice. I think GINOLA'S stay at the lane could
be very brief. (Ed: How wrong could I be?! )
I shall leave the more structured reporting to Brian (Judson), and
Ivan (Cohen), but just comment briefly about the players:-
WALKER - gave a competent performance, but was getting a bit
of stick from the crowd in the first half for not releasing the
ball earlier. (7/10)
CARR - a good showing in the 4-4-2 formation, and probably his
best match so far (7/10)
EDINBURGH - say what you like; I think he's come on leaps and
bounds over the last year, and that he played really well ( 8/10
CALDERWOOD - scored with a powerful header from near the edge
of the box, from a SINTON free kick, after little DOMINGUEZ had
been fouled. He also defended really well, having one of his best
performances for the team. The competition for the centre back
position is really tough!(8/10)
SCALES- got caught out once or twice, and gave the ball away
needlessly at times too, but generally recovered well, and
pleased the crowd when going forward. (7/10)
HOWELLS - his usual showing. Fed DOMINGUEZ quite well when
going forward, and got stuck in as usual (6/10)Missed ( dollied
over) the penalty won by the little man near the end.
CLEMENCE - I suppose he's got the ANDERTON position, and until
a certain individual is fit again, he'll hold his own. His lack
of experience and expertise does show at times, but he holds and
passes the ball well. (7/10)
SINTON - was another crowd pleaser, playing left side
midfield, with GINOLA in the middle behind the front two. A couple
of times SINTON seemed to steal GINOLA'S thunder, by carrying the
ball from outside left into dangerous positions. He had a couple
of shots himself. He got crocked in the second half and the bench
asked him what he wanted to do. SINTON tried to run off his knock
for ages, when he should have been taken off straight away.
GINOLA - enough said already ( 5/10 )
DOMINGUEZ - also enough said already but I'm giving him 10 out of 10!!
FERDINAND, and IVERSEN - neither of these impressed today. They are not
playing well off each other. IVERSEN didn't look match fit, and
showed very few of the running, and defence beating skills that
we saw last season. They both improved in the second half, but it
was still a moderate performance. FERDINAND missed a sitter in
front of goal, and why didn't he take the penalty. Obviously it
was a captain's decision, but surely our main striker ought to be
whacking them in? ( 5/10 )
NIELSEN - came on for SINTON, and impressed me. He got booked with his first touch! but went on to
feed the attack well.
Generally speaking, we gave Derby too much possession in the
first half, but I don't think they really threatened us. They
were missing ASANOVIC, who usually orchestrates their play. We
didn't get going until DOMINGUEZ entered the scene, and the only
thing I'd say is that we didn't capitalise on the possession we
had, and convert enough chances to win by the 2 or 3 goals we
Finally, I am very impressed with my temporary seat
in the south upper. It doesn't matter now when you buggers in the
lower tier stand up, because I can still see all the action! Also
because the rake is sharper (i.e. the stand rises higher, quicker
), I don't seem to be quite so far from the goal at the far end.
The only thing is I've got a bloke sitting a few rows behind me
who sounds like he's on helium:) OLE, OLE,OLE. OLE - JOSE!!!!!!!
· Read the preview for this game.
· All the Spurs Stats you could hope for here! THFC6061 Sports Stats
Top of page | Index to 1997-98 Match Reports